Negative feedback on photos you like and your projects
Is negative feedback an issue and how does it compared to the culture of praise on Flickr and similar?
Let me set the picture: You know your interests are a bit leftfield (unusual) and that what you are really interested in photographing isn’t mainstream interest. The feedback is largely positive but you occasionally get some negative feedback; some pretty scathing – how should you feel, and how should you react?
Flickr
Flickr is a great website; and one that I probably use most frequently to discover new work from a worldwide audience but also as a gallery for my own work. It also is a forum for critique and feedback but it is patently obvious that little negative feedback is posted (and you can argue why should it) and a lot of back patting is going on; some very justified, some dubiously so. It is easy to get used to positivity so it would seem that where negative feedback arises a very knee jerk spat can come out, or a defensive attitude. Sometimes it just results in what is negative feedback going to achieve.
We have all in some way, become accustomed to positive feedback over negative feedback.
YouTube
I put a short slideshow together on YouTube to show a range of pictures I was exhibiting two weeks ago at the Open University. It seems fairly well received for what is essentially my rather (as the mainstream would have it) dull subject of suburbia and a town called Milton Keynes. Today I received some negative feedback, which the author seems to have deleted but I still had the email notification. The nub of the criticism was that it was a waste of five minutes of their life.
So how should you react?
Instinctively, the natural reaction is to defend yourself. And a good measure of that is no bad thing in my book. Without some defence of the self, where is your self integrity going to go? But should you feel that perhaps you’re not cut out to take pictures, or that your project is a doomed idea?
Of course not. The best way to take it is actually for what one person has said, that my pictures were a waste of time for somebody. It’s also worth taking on board that a lot more people will have seen my pictures and have brushed over them and have been bored by them, found them dismal or indeed just bad pictures.
This is a fact.
I myself don’t like every photograph I see, or every piece of music I hear, nor every painting. So neither should I expect any different about my work.
So your attitude to negative feedback should be to take it on board if there is useful criticism; but if one person or a few are dulled by what they see of their work; don’t give up. Reflect, look at your work and ask yourself whether it works for you. If it does, keep going but don’t be adverse to taking on people’s points of view, they may have some very useful to suggest to you; ways in which you can improve.
I believe in my Milton Keynes project. It’s very much leftfield, it’s perhaps rather dull to some people (maybe even most people) – but I’m, not giving up on it, because I know I may push this project as much as I can and it may never go anywhere. But I’m getting satisfaction from it and I’m enjoying it. It is worth hanging on to this because at least you’ll have a finished article you are pleased with.
So the message is, expect criticism, expect savage criticism, and be prepared to take some onboard. But also be prepared to stand up for yourself where you honestly feel you can. If you can’t stand by your favourite work, then who will? If you like one of your pictures but no one else does, it doesn’t really matter, does it?
Written by lilserenity on February 5th, 2010 with no comments.
Read more articles on otherSoftware and Uncategorized.







